I wouldn't be able to choose either. There is someone I would want to date in almost every single book I read! There are two many awesome boys out there for me to choose. Kristinahttp://ladybugstorytime.blogspot.com/
Oh, totally agree with the Uglies series being underrated! I read it earlier this spring and loved it!
Oh, Shay would be a great character to be! Plus, she goes through the transformations that Tally does as well, so it would be interesting to see it all from her point of view. New follower :)